True Healing Discussion (Live 6/25)

IceIXIceIX Posts: 3,358ADMINISTRATORS Site Admin
edited February 2015 in MPQ General Discussion
New feature: True Healing
    Characters receive true healing if their powers heal their wounds. Character powers that ease combat but don't heal wounds provide temporary health. - The following abilities are considered true healing:
    - Ares (Dark Avengers): Sunder - This ability is more a moment of weakness than actual damage, so Ares gains health back when the weakness passes. - Daken (Classic) and (Dark Avengers Wolverine): Healing & Heat - Wolverine (Patch) and (Astonishing X-Men): Healing Factor - Wolverine (X-Force): Recovery
- The following abilities are considered temporary healing:
    - Black Widow (Original): Anti-Gravity Device - This ability uses gravitic fields that lets heroes fight more easily despite injuries. It doesn't heal them of these injuries however. - Spider-Man (Classic): Web Bandages - These bandages help heroes fight through pain but do not provide actual healing. - She-Hulk (Modern): Reprieve – She-Hulk allows for the team to take a rest from combat for a moment and gather their strength but does not heal any wounds.

Edit 2: We've also finished up planning on a companion to this new change. This additional change will result in a reduction in time needed to naturally regen characters for most characters in the game.

Old Healing Rates
    - All characters regain 12 health/minute - Wolverine and Daken regain 24 health per minute

New Healing Rates
    - 2* characters regain 18 health/minute (1.5x faster) - 3* characters regain 24 health/minute (2x faster) - 4* characters regain 30 health/minute (2.5x faster) - Characters with significant regenerative powers: Wolverine, Daken, Spider-Man, Hulk, and She-Hulk regain health at double the rate.

Edit: Added some reasoning from further in the thread
One of the intentions with this change is to cut down on things like Prologue Healing, which prolongs play time through something that is pretty obviously just a time intensive process that doesn't involve actual strong gameplay. It's something people do because it's there, much like tanking. It's not something that's fun. It's not something that's enjoyable. It's something that exists and is taken advantage of because of pure efficiency.

What we intend, and continue to drill in on is that we want players to have a broad mix of characters instead of a Top 3 that is their sole team to play with. In Versus this is a bit rougher of a prospect as players that battle have their last winning team placed on defense. So it's not always the best idea to fight with a less powerful defensive team in order to make up more points. That's something that we're always thinking about. We've discussed allowing players to set a defensive team, but with many other games out with similar versus situations this results in a very precise meta-game where an extremely large percentage of the user base chooses the same defenders. That's not a very fun time for most players.

However, in Events, we continually buff different characters, and outside of Heroics, still allow for characters to be used that aren't buffed. What we want players to do is to play with the breadth of their roster instead of using Spider-Man or Black Widow as necessary crutches and only building 3 other characters. This change is intended to result in exactly this as players see that they can't just rely on in-battle healing and look for other ways besides spending Health Packs to continue playing. We want you to keep playing on your own schedule. We want you to play with multiple characters. Doing so keeps players on their toes and making them think of character combinations that they wouldn't otherwise go with if they weren't forced out of their single set of heroes.


  • AkaTobi_85AkaTobi_85 Posts: 42
    So does this mean that once the match is over, any damage that they've sustained comes back? Would that also potentially knock out a character if they're under 0 HP after this false healing goes away?
  • pallmallpallmall Posts: 36
    wow, this really takes a chunk out of Oh Bee Dub's usefulness. Pre release nerf of Shulkie, and second round nerf bat for Spidey. icon_rolleyes.gif
  • PhantronPhantron Posts: 8,299
    It's hard for me to tell what mechanism is intended but I'd think OBW can actually heal a bit more if her heal is temporary, same with Spiderman.

    I think Patch and Daken should have their abilities changed so that true healing is only provided at the highest levels, and it probably shouldn't be 100% true healing.
  • SteveSSteveS Posts: 26
    Way to omit just enough detail to prevent meaningful discussion.
  • gamargamar Posts: 1,733
    AkaTobi_85 wrote:
    So does this mean that once the match is over, any damage that they've sustained comes back? Would that also potentially knock out a character if they're under 0 HP after this false healing goes away?

    Hopefully once a character gets temp HP all damage is applied to the temp HP until it runs out, so damage wouldn't "come back"
  • DayvDayv Posts: 4,185GLOBAL_MODERATORS Community Moderator
    So this is how prologue healing gets removed.

    Healers are just as good on defense, but lose their awesomeness on offense. Overall I don't mind the change, but I've stopped using team healing regularly since the Spidey nerf.

    This will change meta a lot, and might require rebalancing of some of the healing abilities in the long run, most particularly Spidey's where the only secondary effect is the possible removal of webs.
    [This is my mod voice. I don't use it much.]
    Otherwise, I'm just another poster.
    I am not an employee of D3Go, Demiurge, or Hibernia. All opinions are my own, or are poorly worded jokes.
    In game: Dayv
  • ChimaeraChimaera Posts: 1,013
    edited June 2014
    Ya I don't get it.

    Does temporary healing only permanently heal damage done in that match?

    If you take any damage and heal that damage are you fully healed at the end of the match or not?

    If you take damage then try and heal it in a different game, does your health return to the previous value once the match is done?

    Are you adjusting the health regeneration factor so covers don't take 11 hours to regenerate?
    Once Emperor of the:
  • pasa_pasa_ Posts: 2,899
    Discussion? Guess we are supposed to GUESS that the heck the terms temporary and other words mean?

    How about writing down in plain English up front and/or provide some example of what happens in-game and after the game.
    Ex 15th original member of logo3.png quit at start of Season 4.
  • GhastGhast Posts: 1,273
    I think he forgot to cut and paste a paragraph in his haste to get in and out of here without actually communicating with anyone.
    Former MPQ player, current Puzzles and Dragons convert.
  • gamargamar Posts: 1,733
    pasa_ wrote:
    Discussion? Guess we are supposed to GUESS that the heck the terms temporary and other words mean?

    How about writing down in plain English up front and/or provide some example of what happens in-game and after the game.
    I assume it works like D&D's temporary hit points:
    Certain effects give a character temporary hit points. When a character gains temporary hit points, note his current hit point total. When the temporary hit points go away [in MPQ I assume this is when the battle ends] the character’s hit points drop to the noted hit point total. If the character’s hit points are below his noted hit point total at that time, all the temporary hit points have already been lost and the character’s hit point total does not drop further.
  • mohiomohio Posts: 1,638 Chairperson of the Boards
    edited June 2014
    Time to grab some popcorn icon_e_wink.gif Thread's about to blow up.

    edit: Also, I'm just as confused as everyone else. It *seems* like once you take damage that damage is forever on that character, and even healing with OBW/Spidey/She-Hulk in the same battle will only be temporary. However it's so vague, it might only be that all damage sustained at the end of a match cannot be healed back to full health in subsequent matches outside of "true" healing, which is effectively only nerfing prologue-style healing (although I will often heal my Thor/Pun an extra 1-2k in some matches and bring them back to max over the course of a couple matches, so it's not strictly prologue healing). If it's the former, it's a big change and I'm not a fan, but I will adjust. If it's the latter, I'm not sure I really care all that much and am completely fine with it.
  • SpoitSpoit Posts: 3,386 Chairperson of the Boards
    So, it marks the health at the time of the cast, and then anything above that is lost after the battle? I guess it would be too much to hope for for the temporary health to actually be able to exceed the maximum, without wasting it in that case.

    Any estimate of the time frame IceIX?
  • gamargamar Posts: 1,733
    mohio wrote:
    Time to grab some popcorn icon_e_wink.gif Thread's about to blow up.

    OBW still OP
    Spidey still tinykitty
    Sentry hugely nerfed

  • GhastGhast Posts: 1,273
    The fireworks start flying when they gently nudge the price of health packs to 500 HP for 4 a week after this change takes place.
    gamar wrote:
    Sentry hugely nerfed

    Only for f2p and whales. The cheaters get free healing anyway and the Krakens can afford to pay $100 a week on the game.
    Former MPQ player, current Puzzles and Dragons convert.
  • SpoitSpoit Posts: 3,386 Chairperson of the Boards
    Talking about spidey, does this swing the preferred build back to 3/5/5?
  • I would guess any health gained from the temporary characters only last during that match and the character goes to their previous health post match where Patch, Daken, etc. are able to truly heal.

    This makes sense and as someone who has never used a healing character to heal myself I am ok with this change but I know a lot of people won't be happy. Hopefully this leads to less OBW being used, getting tired of her.
  • So the terrible healing mechanics just got worse?!
  • eidehuaeidehua Posts: 521 Critical Contributor
    I am thinking the temporary health is basically just a shield that lasts the duration of a match. Damage will go through that shield first. However, unlike a real shield it won't go over the characters max health the way it's worded.
  • jozierjozier Posts: 1,920
    edited June 2014
    Spidey is now legitimately the worst character in the game.

    His only feature is to temporarily heal someone in battle? At the cost of 12 yellow AP? Or for an extra bonus of 15!! blue AP he can heal for another 700?

    Why would anyone voluntarily use him?
  • NarkonNarkon Posts: 1,030
    They try to make sense of temporary and "true" healing and they offer an explanation with the nerf to try and justify the change. How about you make a change that makes sense and cut down the time it takes to fully heal a downed character? 8 hours to heal a hero? I guess you really want to to drive away people, don't you?
    So how can we heal heroes now? Oh, wait, I guess I should say offer 'true' healing to our heroes. Only with healing packs? How about dropping the ridiculous HP price for healing packs then?
    Sigh. P2P all the way.
This discussion has been closed.