ard021 said: You have Nissa 2 and Nissa 3 reversed (Nissa 2 is the mono-green one with the Energize abilities, Nissa 3 is the blue-green one with Cycling abilities.)
Quantius said: 13 are broken/overpowered and 22 are good/weak/bad? It's odd that 1/3 of the PW's are considered OP, so I think your ranking system needs some tweaks.Broken insinuates that it's degenerate and nearly impossible to overcome. In paper, things that are broken end up on the banned/restricted list. Are these PW's that far gone? Maybe, but I'm not wholly convinced here.Overpowered, but overpowered compared to what? The "Good" ones? You go from OP to Good to Weak. There are no average PW's in MTGPQ that are neither good nor weak? Maybe the OP category is actually the "Good" list and the Good list is Average? Just feels odd that an entire category is simply missing.Rather than have Weak and Bad categories, PW's that are poor performers because of keywords/types that have rotated out should be exempted from the list and filed under "Need a redesign". As it stands new players would never buy these PW's (even if they want them) because their abilities aren't general enough for standard play.
Quantius said: As it stands new players would never buy these PW's (even if they want them) because their abilities aren't general enough for standard play.