Hit Monkey's red power interaction with Chasm and She-Hulk

HoundofShadow

After downing either Chasm or She-Hulk with 3* Hit-Monkey's red, Chasm's passive will trigger the destruction of his Abyss tiles but he doesn't revive. As for She-Hulk, her passive destruction of columns will trigger after you end your turn. Here's the video of Hit Monkey's red and She-Hulk's passive revive.

https://streamable.com/kfiuty

Could the dev confirm if this is a bug or this is supposed to happen?

MoosePrime

The ability only says the downed character can't revive themself, it doesn't say that other on-downed things don't happen.

ShionSinX

@MoosePrime said:
The ability only says the downed character can't revive themself, it doesn't say that other on-downed things don't happen.

Those effects activate on revival, not on death. If they arent reviving they should not trigger.

HoundofShadow

Strangely enough, it didn't trigger iHulk's passive that deals friendly AoE to his allies, which comes together with his revive. It looks like the coding order for interaction of iHulk's revive is different from Chasm and She-Hulk. Maybe the dev could compare the coding order for them?

MoosePrime

@ShionSinX said:

@MoosePrime said:
The ability only says the downed character can't revive themself, it doesn't say that other on-downed things don't happen.

Those effects activate on revival, not on death. If they arent reviving they should not trigger.

She-Hulk's black says "When downed... She-Hulk is revived ... and uses So Below".
Chasm's purple says "If Chasm is downed ... Chasm is revived... then he destroys all Abyss tiles."
Hulk's Black says "When Downed,... the Immortal Hulk is revived ... [and] deals damage to his allies"

My reading of all these powers could be reactions to being Downed, not the revival. The "then" in Chasm's appears chronological rather than conditional because the revival clause appears before it, and is conditional on the amount of Abyss tiles.

Hit Monkey's red prevents the revivals, but it doesn't say anything about preventing other 'on Downed' effects.

Perhaps the bug is that Hulk does not damage his allies when he is downed with Hit Monkey's red.

DevpoolMPQ_BCS

Thanks for calling this out! This was actually intended functionality, but after some deliberation, we're going to move forward with matching the expected behavior noted in this thread.