Prodigious Growth does not stack in some cases [Fixed in 3.1]

TheDude1
TheDude1 Posts: 194 Tile Toppler
I've run into an odd case where Prodigious Growth does not stack in some circumstances.  I think it's based on how it enters your hand: when I draw more than one copy, it seems to work fine, even if I cast both copies on the same creature.  But if I use Muldrotha's ability to bring it back from the graveyard after it was cast once and try to cast it on the same creature a second time, it doesn't seem to do anything.  I'm not sure if there are other means of bringing it back that might cause the same issue to test it out...

//Edited Title - Brigby

Comments

  • Enygma6
    Enygma6 Posts: 266 Mover and Shaker
    I had seen similar behavior with Knight's Pledge a month ago, but that topic got buried here on the forums:  
    https://forums.d3go.com/discussion/74828/knights-pledge-buffs-do-not-stack#latest

    I don't recall if that one failed on multiple copies being cast, or if it was the same card being cast multiple times.  The only screenshot I have from that incident shows a Muldrotha in play, so I was likely digging it back up that way at the time.  

    There are other cards besides Muldrotha to dig spells out of the graveyard, this behavior might warrant testing with some of those:
    Flood of Recollection
    Seasons Past
    Wildest Dreams
    Recolect
    The Mirari Conjecture
    Harness the Storm
    Salvager of Secrets
    Tiana, Ship's Caretaker (will work because both Prodigious Growth and Knight's Pledge are Auras)

    There may be others.  
    I'm pretty sure the deck I was testing had Muldrotha and Tiana, because I had also picked up Druid of Horns at the time and was testing it with repeating Auras.
  • TheDude1
    TheDude1 Posts: 194 Tile Toppler
    Interesting test results:

    Cast Prodigious Growth on Radha once, then pulled it back with Recollect.  Played it again on Radha, but nothing happened.

    Radha dies, cast Tiana.  Tiana pulls Prodigious back with her ability, and I cast that copy on Tiana.  This time it works, but it's only the first cast on Tiana.  She pulls it back again and I'm able to cast it a fourth time (not sure how I managed to keep the match going this long) but this copy it doesn't stack when I cast it on Tiana.  Match ended before I could try it a fifth time to see if the graveyard copy would cast on another creature.

    Summary:

    Pulling back from graveyard seems to be ok IF it's the first cast on a given creature.  But if it comes back from the graveyard, it won't stack if cast on the same creature a second+ time.
  • Tombstone
    Tombstone ADMINISTRATORS Posts: 1,208 Chairperson of the Boards
    I've relayed this to the team, and they have confirmed that there does appear to be an issue with cards such as Prodigious Growth and Knight's Pledge being used again on the same creature after being returned from the Graveyard. I'll go ahead and add this to the bug list.