khurram said: Omniscience, The Masterpiece should fade to legacy as it is, where it belongs.If they decide to include it in M19 it ought to be an entirely new card, at mythic rarity and balanced.
gogol666 said: khurram said: Omniscience, The Masterpiece should fade to legacy as it is, where it belongs.If they decide to include it in M19 it ought to be an entirely new card, at mythic rarity and balanced. I completely disagree with you: the omniscience reprinted in m19 is exactly the same omniscience of HOU. That's why it is called a reprint
gogol666 said: I don't know if ignoring reprints is fine, since you don't give much of an argument to your opinion. However, core sets in the paper mtg always had a group of cards in common among the different editions and that, in my opinion, helped to build some continuity while jumping through the different planes. Origins had that function for mtgpq so far and going towards m19 origins is the set that is going to be replaced (together with hou). Thus, ignoring reprints sounds much worse (to me) if origins is being rotated with m19, because we are losing a lot of the continuity offered by it.Of course I'm missing a lot some official information about m19 and d3/oktagon's view about it
EDHdad said: Nobody cares about "reprints". They care about Omniscience.It should either be Nerfed and downshifted to a Mythic, or it should be Nerfed and remain a Masterpiece, or it should be Nerfed and deleted from the Puzzle Quest catalog.Also, Etali shouldn't have haste. At least, not until I can get my hands on one.
EDHdad said: Also, Etali shouldn't have haste. At least, not until I can get my hands on one.