We've had Blade, then Ghost Rider, then Blade again. Historical evidence suggests that we'll get a 5* Ghost Rider this year.
That said, we're already bracing ourselves for a 5* Thor to a) fill out the MCU Avengers in 5* tier, and b) tie into the movie. We could still get a 4* release, or another one of those 5/3* splits with two different characters.
Although last time this happened we got a Tiny Elektra, so maybe a 3* Ghost Rider? That would satisfy multiple conditions. I'm thinking Hela could be a good candidate as well; movie tie-in and suitably scary for Halloween.