Awaken summon elemental mana costs

Options
Morphis
Morphis Posts: 975 Critical Contributor
edited June 2016 in MtGPQ General Discussion
I was trying Lilian's reanimator while I wait for better version once I open my pcks(hopefully).

One card ended up being so much better than I thought: ruinous path.
I thought it was very efficient but sometimes could end being slow because of half charge.
On average good.

I was wrong

The awaken effect comes into play so many times Ina a control deck like this one.
In the end it really fits the deck and performs greatly.

So I figured: maybe other awaken are this good, I underestimated the whole thing.
But.... No. Other awaken effects are so much more expensive and for less benefit.

So the question is: why?
How comes a card that is already extremely efficient in itself(5 mana non conditional removal? Sign me up) has the best summon elemental awaken attached to it?(11 mana awaken: summon 6 tokens)

Or I should say... Why other awaken effects have so much higher mana cost?

Some examples:

Boiling Earth16 mana, 4 tokens
Clutch of Currents 12 mana, 3 tokens
Coastal Discovery 12 mana, 4 tokens
Earthen Arms 16 mana, 4 tokens

There are many others...
I can understand some being a little better caus of color/base effect(even if still: ruinous path base effect is great), card rarity or design choice...
But here the difference is between good and "no way anyone will ever use this".

Comments

  • Plastic
    Plastic Posts: 762 Critical Contributor
    Options
    Things like this make me feel like the game is rushed, poorly tested and seemingly in alpha phase still. If it's just JC testing these things then I can understand, I guess. If not, then they need to get this stuff wrapped up better.
  • span_argoman
    span_argoman Posts: 751 Critical Contributor
    Options
    JC has mentioned this in the forums before. Awaken elemental costs are based on rarity:
    Common - 4 mana/elemental
    Uncommon - 3 mana/elemental
    Rare - 2 mana/elemental

    The only thing that changes is the number of elementals for each Awaken spell.
  • Sinslayer5
    Sinslayer5 Posts: 45
    Options
    The rarity differential makes sense - the question is more a matter of cost versus benefit. I understand wanting to separate the value of certain cards with the mechanic, but at such a wide margin...

    Also an extremely useful Awaken spell in a control deck? Rush of Ice.