Fun with rankings!

mischiefmaker

I thought it'd be fun to have another community project; except this time, it'll be subjective!

Inspired by DumDumDugn's "rank the colors" thread, the concept is easy: rank all the characters from best to worst, no ties allowed. When you're done, put your username in bold and I'll add your vote to an overall average ranking.

There are also separate rankings for powers, separated by color. Feel free to vote for those too!

Ranking sheet is here.

Unknown

Interesting. Would it be wise to just automate the rankings somehow? Like the names are pre-set and we just add a number, 1-29, for each?

Nonce Equitaur 2

I'd rank them as follows:

                             Max Tile Damage         Power Cost
       Name         Max HP  Ye Re Bu Pu Gr Bk     Ye Re Bu Pu Gr Bk  
01 Magneto (Class)    5800 |52·60·67·10·11·12| - |  · 2| 5·10|  ·  |  
02 Ragnarok           7111 |10·51·10·11·51·10| - |  · 2|  ·  | 6·  |  
03 Spider-Man         5800 |67·12·52·60·11·10| - | 9·  | 2· *|  ·  |   
04 The Hood           4350 |67·12·60·11·10·52| - |14·  | *·  |  · 9|   
05 Thor               5340 |45·50·10· 9·39·11| - |11· 6|  ·  |13·  |   
06 Black Widow (Grey) 5075 |11·12·60·67·10·52| - |  ·12|  ·11|15·  |  
07 Storm (Classic)    2670 |39·11·45· 9·50·10| - | *·  |11·  |12·  |   
08 Iron Man (Mod 40)  7250 |60·67·52·12·11·10| - | 6·13|20·  |  ·  |  
09 The Punisher       5800 |10·52·11·12·60·67| - |  · 8|  ·  | 8· 7|  
10 Wolverine (X-Men)  3560 |39·45· 9·11·50·10| - | *·10|  ·  | 3·  |  
11 Daken              2920 | 8· 9· 9·32·41·37| - |  ·  |  · *|  · *|  
12 Captain America    4450 |50·45·39· 9·10·11| - |19·11|12·  |  ·  |  
13 Black Widow (Orig) 3315 |10·11·45· 9·50·39| - |  ·  |11· 5|  · *|   
14 Storm (Modern)     1620 | 7·27· 7· 8·31·24| - |  · 5|  ·  |10· 9|   
15 Wolverine (X-For)  9328 |55·62·10· 9·70· 9| - |10·15|  ·  |15·  |  
16 Doctor Doom        5440 | 9· 9·53·41·10·47| - |  ·  | 9·  |  ·12|  
17 Magneto (Marvel)   3560 |11·39·50·45· 9·10| - |  · 8| 6·  | 9·  |   
18 Venom              2640 | 6· 7· 7·19·25·22| - |  ·  |  · 4|  ·12|   
19 Juggernaut (Class) 3520 | 7·22· 6· 7·25· 9| - |  · 6|  ·  | 6·  |   
20 Iron Man (Mod 35)  2700 |27·31·24· 8· 7· 7| - | 8·10|19·  |  ·  |   
21 Hawkeye (Mod)      2670 |11·39·45·50· 9·10| - |  ·10|10· *|  ·  |   
22 Loki (Dark Reign)  4148 |10· 9·11·57·44·51| - |  ·  |  · 5|  ·11|   
23 Bullseye           2190 | 9· 8· 9·41·32·37| - |  ·  |  · *|  ·16|   
24 Moonstone          4450 | 9·45·11·50·10·39| - |  ·11|  · 5|  ·17|   
25 Spider-Man (Bag)   3560 |39·11·45·50·10· 9| - | 7·  | 9·13|  ·  |   
26 Hawkeye (Class)    1320 |19·22· 7·25· 6· 7| - | 7·  |  ·14|  ·  |   
27 Invisible Woman    6996 |70·10·62· 9·55· 9| - |19·  |14·  |12·  |   
28 Black Widow (Mod)  1540 |19· 7·22·25· 6· 7| - |  ·  | 9·10|  ·  |  
29 Yelena Belova      1540 | 6· 7·19·25· 7·22| - |  ·  |  ·13|  ·13| 

mischiefmaker

I wanted to automate the rankings, but in doing my own ranking I found it way easier to move names around than it was to move numbers around.

Nonce Equitaur 2

You should probably have a new sheet that has one column of names, and then the numbers for each person.

Also have a column of totals, and do sorting by that column.

mischiefmaker

Already done. I'll make it public once there are more results.

Nonce Equitaur 2

The top three and bottom three look fairly consistent.

mischiefmaker

It's a bit early (only five responses so far, plus one incomplete), but yes, it's pretty clear there's a Big 3. #4 is also pretty clear and the bottom 5 are well established too.

More people should enter their rankings! You know you've got time, it's the holidays and there's only one event going on right now.

Unknown

Added my list... this will likely change if I ever get enough Hood Covers to level him appropriately. And Punisher I have ranked almost completely on potential as I only have the red cover at 1.

mischiefmaker

If you change your ranking, you should post here when you do, else your changed ranking won't get factored into the overall.

Nonce Equitaur 2

You may as well add a CONSENSUS column, that ranks them by their current consensus. Just copy the column from the other spreadsheet you mentioned.

Unknown

mischiefmaker wrote:

If you change your ranking, you should post here when you do, else your changed ranking won't get factored into the overall.

Will do.

Unknown

Can I just post mine here?

WIP--I think I'm about done. Might change my mind later and when Hulk's max stats get released, I'll rank him properly.

Hulk (not really, but I wish )
Ragnarok
Magneto (classic)
Spider-Man
Thor
Punisher
Wolverine (yellow)
Doctor Doom
Black Widow (grey suit)
Iron Man (Model 40)
The Hood
Daken
Storm (Classic)
Black Widow (Original)
Captain America
Storm (Modern)
Moonstone
Hawkeye (Modern)
Black Widow (Modern)
Magneto (Marvel NOW)
Juggernaut
Bullseye
Wolverine (X-Force)
Loki
Hawkeye (Classic)
Iron Man (Model 35)
Venom
Bag-Man
Yelena
Invisible Woman

Unknown

how the hell is IW not dead last.

mischiefmaker

Sure, if you just post here, I'll transfer it to the sheet. That way people can discuss and/or heckle more easily.

GameloftNYC wrote:

how the hell is IW not dead last.

Sounds like someone else wants to do a ranking

Unknown

GameloftNYC wrote:

how the hell is IW not dead last.

Having not looked at the rankings, I'd bet people are putting BagMan below her.

I'd put both 4*s at the end -- they're nominally better than BagMan, but the amount of ISO (and covers) needed to make them even vaguely useful is just ridiculous.

Unknown

I dunno if IW is better than Bag-Man. IW's skills are too expensive. Bag-Man's purple is at least usable. As is his yellow in PVE. The best thing about IW is that she helps you easier suceed in events due to her requirements.

Nonce Equitaur 2

10/51/10/11/51/11 -- Ragnarok (Dark Avengers Thor)
67/12/52/60/11/10 -- Spider-Man (Classic)
52/60/67/10/11/12 -- Magneto (Classic)
45/50/10/09/39/11 -- Thor (Marvel NOW!)
11/12/60/67/10/52 -- Black Widow (Grey Suit)
39/11/45/09/50/10 -- Storm (Classic)
60/67/52/12/11/10 -- Iron Man (Model 40)
39/45/09/11/50/10 -- Wolverine (Astonishing X-Men)
09/09/53/41/10/47 -- Doctor Doom (Classic)
10/52/11/12/60/67 -- The Punisher (Dark Reign)
67/12/60/11/10/52 -- The Hood (Classic)
10/11/45/50/09/39 -- Black Widow (Original)
08/09/09/32/41/37 -- Daken (Dark Avengers Wolverine)
11/39/50/45/09/10 -- Magneto (Marvel NOW!)
07/27/07/08/31/24 -- Storm (Modern)
19/07/22/25/06/07 -- Black Widow (Modern)
06/07/07/19/25/22 -- Venom (Dark Avengers Spider-Man)
11/39/45/50/09/10 -- Hawkeye (Modern)
27/31/24/08/07/07 -- Iron Man (Model 35)
50/45/39/09/10/11 -- Captain America (Modern)
55/62/10/09/70/09 -- Wolverine (X-Force)
10/09/11/57/44/51 -- Loki (Dark Reign)
07/22/06/07/25/09 -- Juggernaut (Classic)
09/08/09/41/32/37 -- Bullseye (Dark Avengers Hawkeye)
09/45/11/50/10/39 -- Moonstone (Dark Avengers Ms. Marvel)
70/10/62/09/55/09 -- Invisible Woman (Classic)
19/22/07/25/06/07 -- Hawkeye (Classic)
39/11/45/50/10/09 -- Spider-Man (Bag-Man)
06/07/19/25/07/22 -- Yelena Belova (Dark Avengers Widow)

mischiefmaker

I assume this is your new ranking? If so, updated.

Nonce Equitaur 2

Lets see the ranking sheet now that we've got more opinions up.

Unknown

Spider-Man (Classic)
Ragnarok (Dark Avengers Thor)
Magneto (Classic)
Wolverine (Astonishing X-Men)
Thor (Marvel NOW!)
The Punisher (Dark Reign)
Iron Man (Model 40)
Hulk (Indestructible)
Black Widow (Grey Suit)
The Hood (Classic)
Storm (Classic)
Black Widow (Original)
Daken (Dark Avengers Wolverine)
Storm (Modern)
Doctor Doom (Classic)
Black Widow (Modern)
Loki (Dark Reign)
Hawkeye (Modern)
Captain America (Modern)
Venom (Dark Avengers Spider-Man)
Iron Man (Model 35)
Bullseye (Dark Avengers Hawkeye)
Moonstone (Dark Avengers Ms. Marvel)
Wolverine (X-Force)
Juggernaut (Classic)
Magneto (Marvel NOW!)
Hawkeye (Classic)
Spider-Man (Bag-Man)
Yelena Belova (Dark Avengers Widow)
Invisible Woman (Classic)